Social Trends, Vol. 09

Permanent URI for this collectionhttps://ir.nbu.ac.in/handle/123456789/4641

EDITORIAL

Cultural Appropriation and Consumption in Neo-Liberal Times

Modern capitalism thrives by transforming everything into saleable and consumable commodity. In this exercise nothing, from the elements of nature to forms and practices of culture, is spared. The glut of nature – the climate, the greenery, the forest, the sea, river, mountains, the rains, the wild animals, the snow-clad valley, the sight of snow fall, the snow-covered hilltops with golden plume, the blue sky, the space – everything finely packaged and offered to tourists and “nature lovers” as commodity of irreplaceable value. The tourism industry, largely controlled by the big capital, can manipulate all conservation laws, in league with the ever-willing political elite, and finds its way for making profit while severely toppling the ecological balance and serenity. The opening up of the lush green tea gardens in North Bengal for promotion of tourism industry is a typical example.

Similarly, the elements of material culture like archaeological preserves, historical places, monuments, places of religious importance - the ancient idols, the mosques, temples, gurdwaras and churches – and the socio-cultural practices in the form of festivals and rituals, beliefs and sentiments and the emotions associated with religion, the folk forms of music and dance - are often appropriated in the reproduction of popular cultural forms and activities, using the media like films, television, radio and magazines, which together function as the “culture industry”1 (to use the phraseology of Adorno). The mass media of different forms are used for mass circulation of these appropriated and mediated commodities; the culture industry thus thrives by reproducing and packaging the rich reserve of any given culture in a society.

The “culture industry” uses the elements of culture, the religious and social sentiments, as a huge reserve of raw material to be SOCIAL TRENDS Journal of the Department of Sociology of North Bengal University Vol. 9, 31 March 2022; ISSN: 2348-6538 Peer-reviewed National Journal reproduced again and again. The transformation of elements of culture, which are often representation of a collective tradition and part of social memory, helps reproduction of culture and all its associated beliefs and values without hurting the public sentiments and carefully avoiding peoples’, politicians’ and institutional rebuff; the prime idea being to cash in on peoples’ emotion. Thus, the possibility of a logical-critical-scientific treatment of tradition and culture, which would have helped in the generation of scientific and critical mind-set is nipped in the bud. Such a “with the tide” (uncritical and all-permissible) treatment of culture is of course rooted in larger business motive, based on careful calculation of the nature of consumers for commercial films and television serials as well as soaps and series on digital platform. However, the covert function of such reproduction of culture is to sustain and expand a space for a kind of politics that thrives by cultivating cultural sentiments and peoples’ religious affiliations. It nurtures a brand of politics that most often thrives on religious nationalism, apart from other profit-making politico-economic rationale. The 80:20 (or the majority: minority) game is a part of this calculation; the religious and social lives of the minority communities find an unfavourable representation while those of the majority community find overwhelming representation. The privatization of all forms of media and the control of the media by the powerful corporate houses, having close connection with the ruling elite, help appropriation of culture even more effectively to fulfil interests of both parties. The ultimate function of all this is ideological integration of the masses into a socio-political and cultural order that suits the overpowering ruling elite; whether this comes to good use for erasing off the alternative space and varied aesthetic negotiations operational is a different question.

Most of the Indians nurse overwhelming religious sentiments; the mega serials, based on the epics: The Mahabharat and the Ramayan, ran in hundreds of episodes over a few years amidst resounding success generating a strong emotional attachment with the cultural tradition to the extent that the whole nation was doped into the world of fantasy (the imagined unreal yet connected world). A hyperreal moment2 (to use Jean Baudrillard’ phraseology) was thus created whereby the views and viewing of an imaginary world under an emotional spell led to confusing an epic for history. With ever rising viewership the serials helped the culture industry proliferate manifold; the flow of advertisements, boosted the sale of TV sets, initially black and white, then colour, and the accessories that come with TV sets. A large majority of the Indian population, even the rural population, were bombarded with relentless flow of advertisements, at a time when Indian economy and market were growing at a rapid pace in an era of globalization. Apart from doing business in millions, the racking of religious sentiments helped arouse a new sense of Indianness rooted in religious nationalism, which undoubtedly helped the rise of Hindu nationalism and consolidation of BJP in power. The timing of making and airing these serials is noteworthy; late 1980s and early 1990s, when India was gradually and surely turning neo-liberal and global, and the ascending capital, national as well as global, demanding more space to grow. The audio-visual media, especially television, was gradually opened for amassing of private capital, freeing from the monopoly of the government-controlled agencies. The television manufacturing industries grew hand-in-hand with other industries as the latter offer advertisements in order to arouse the collective and imitable passion for relentless consumption. The privately controlled news channels now run 24x7 in connivance of the ruling elite for relentless ideological propaganda to blunt the critical and at times aesthetic faculty of the citizens. Here, I would refer to the idea of aesthetic and its corelate notions of ‘taste’, as proposed by Bourdieu, which often bears the notions of a class-oriented consumption of cultural products and reproduction of culturally significant and defining forms. Such living up to a class-specific ‘taste’ and aesthetic assertions under the influence of ‘cultural capital’ cannot be completely overlooked, but mass media surely pass out some ‘popular cultural’ forms and practices through which many cross the classified-class barriers and become omnivores, feeding upon a culturally hybrid experience and create new aesthetics of consumption.

The pujas and religious functions find relentless reproduction in television serials and programmes; the festive season in Bengal starting with Durga puja, Laxmi puja, Kali puja/Deewali and ending with Bhaiphonta in the months of September-October, alongside the one-month vacation for the people attached to the educational institutions, find overwhelming representation in the television programmes. Every melodramatic serial would devote a number of episodes covering all significant religious or social events. The pujas organized by the politicians and the film stars find special live coverage for about a week; for about a month the Bengalis are in a festive mood and television plays a central part in this celebration.

The celebration of Poila Baisakh (Bengali new year), Christmas, 31st December (the new year celebration), Jamai Sasthi, Bhai Phonta and so on are also voluminously represented in television programmes. The welcoming of the English new year on the night of 31st December is the largest of all social functions celebrated by the middle and upper-class urban Bengalis on and off television; the viewers arrange parties on 31st night with family members and friends, consume alcohol or soft drinks, and for the younger generation this is an occasion for substance abuse; an occasion to be alienated from all frustrations and depressions of life; the urban middle-class switches on the television with the readiness to consume the hypocritical, hypo-real moments created by the socalled celebrities, expressing repugnant gestures on screen; indeed, a perfect example of tittytainment (or cheap entertainment) that tend to set cultural standards for others.

Among other things, all the families and households that find representation on the television screen are joint families with extended kin, friends, villains (from within and outside the kinship net), who are also given a place in the household, even when the serial is located in an urban context where small families and stem families are the rule. The serials progress on the themes of love and marriage and untiringly reproduce joint family values and patriarchal values coated in religious and traditional sentiments. The turn of events, the characters and their relations are completely bereft of the logic of everyday life or human sensitivity, making television the perfect “idiot box”; the omnipresence of gods, temples, gurujis etc. often relegate science and logic of life to the back seat. Even the television serials that are based on historical events and revolutionary time, some such recent television serials being Rani Rashmoni and Kadambini, soon turn religious and get lost in the world of fleeting and provocative sentiments of all kinds. Yet the television serials and programmes occupy a large part of a day’s routine of the lower-middle and middleclass Indians as a large section of the population has been kept out of the labour force, and the common people have discovered television as a means to numbing entertainment in their ample leisure time. Television has become a major part of the life of the retired and the elderly population, which is absorbed in non-creative and timepassing activities by ploys of the culture industry, sustaining and reproducing uncritical selves. The out of workforce population who in the pre-television age used to read and socialise a lot, now they have largely given up the habit of reading and visiting their neighbours and relatives often and without notice.

The archaeological sites of historical and religious importance, with some touch-ups and manoeuvring under the guidance of the state agencies or specially constituted trustee boards, turn out to be lucrative business packages as they, with promotion through advertisements, become favoured tourist destinations. The best business packages are worked out when nature is moderated and “beautified” and the area is developed with modern living facilities and some built-in, cosmetic environmental changes to give physical comfort and aesthetic pleasure (aesthetic pleasure is now a commodity too) to the middle- and upper-class tourists who have made occasional tours an essential means for recreation and status elevation.

The culture transformed into commodities for consumption are often fetishized as they acquire a mystical value, although with considerable use value; goddess Kali coming real in the serial Rani Rashmoni is adored by a large majority of the viewers as a real avatar. The moment goddess Kali comes alive with mystic sounds and light on the screen the viewer’s, women viewers in particular, emotions touch the high point and adorn the goddess with uludhwani (a sound collectively made by the Bengali women on auspicious, particularly religious, occasions by twisting their tongue and moving it rapidly while drawing in air); the hyperreal thus gets confused with the real. In the 1970s we noticed this confluence of real and the mystic during the screening of the religious film Jai Santoshi Maa (1975). The impact of the film was such that goddess Santoshima, who was until then absent in the list of goddesses adored in Bengal, found a permanent place. In West Bengal, the political leaders, particularly those of the ruling political party, enhance their social status by demonstrating their religiosity and devotion in organizing and airing such religious functions. The huge amount of money, often crores, amassed through legal and illegal means in organizing and telecasting Durga puja and Kali puja help the politicians enhance their rating in the vote market. Even prominent Muslim leaders of the present ruling party in West Bengal competes with the Hindu leaders of the same party in organizing Durga puja and nurtures huge fan following. As an icing on the cake the leaders organize cultural programmes (music night) with popular singers, which are also telecasted on television screen. Such appropriation of culture, even if does not bear the testimony of any cultural capital, helps enhancement of social capital, which is used for political ends.

The noteworthy among the implications of the appropriation of culture by the media are (1) misrepresentation or distortion of history, (2) reproduction of myths and un-reason, (3) promotion of tittytainment (4) promotion of religious nationalism and (5) massive wastage of creative labour; the mindless television serials have eaten up the space for the creative performing arts like classical music, theatre and parallel cinema. By whiling time watching television, the otherwise creative people lose their creative aptitude and thought, which, in turn, impact their lives and livelihoods. For instance, the fact that the group theatre is losing viewership could be explained in this light.

Given its wide reach and popularity, television with all its productions, the serials and short films, could have been a fantastic medium for spreading a strong and appropriate sense of history, literature and relevant artistic achievements. India has a rich reserve of literature in its national and regional languages; many such stories and novels have been translated into English and other Indian languages. In the days when Door Darshan had command over all television programmes there were efforts from various corners to make quality serials and films based on true and socially meaningful short stories and novels. Munsi Premchand’s stories, namely, Eidgah, Godaan, Boodhi Kaaki, Nirmala, Namak ka Daroga, Sawa Ser Gehu, Coffin etc., were adapted into television serials; some stories ran for more than 10 episodes, all in 1980s and 1990s. Most of these stories were directed by the film-maker-poet Gulzar. Talented actors like Pankaj Kapoor, Vrajesh Hirjee, Anjann Srivastava, Surekha Sikri, Ravi Jhankal, Jaaved Khan Amrohi, Raghubir Yadav and many others gave soulful and realistic performances, adding to the ‘aesthetic’ value of these programmes.

One of the best short film Tamas was made by the film director Govind Nihalini which was aired on Door Darshan in 1988; the film was based on the Hindi novel written by Bhisham Sahani. Another illustrious film-maker of modern India, Shyam Benegal, made many episodes of Bharat Ek Khonj based on Jawaharlal Nehru’s Discovery of India; such television serial often gave the common Indians an authentic account of Indian history from ancient to modern times. Those were the liberal days under the Congress rule, which had true respect for the rich and diverse cultural traditions that India is. But now, when the television is almost completely controlled by the corporate houses for business and the corporate-political elite alliance is absolute, the culture industry has re-set its objectives to (1) further capitalist interest by making profit and (2) help the political elite in popularizing its political agendum, i.e., to appropriate cultural tradition and promote religious nationalism.

In reproduction of the elements of the given culture in films and television serials and programmes the culture industry had the choice of doing it with social responsibility and by adhering to a set of values or a set of alternative standards. Some such standards could have been honest, authentic and critical representation of the rich cultural traditions, commitment to certain ethical standards which any art form demands, commitment to promotion of scientific temper while sustaining a critical stance towards the unscientific and superstitious elements in the social and cultural practices and so on; and by doing that the industry could have played its part in elevating the overall ‘aesthetic’ experience of the nation. Unfortunately, by going opposite direction primarily to fulfil business ambitions and political compulsions, the culture industry, especially the television industry in India is flouting ethical standards and norms of rightful citizenship and its larger social responsibility.

If the mainstream argument of this discourse is in line with Habermas’s idea of colonization of public space through distorted communication3, the question, along post-structuralist arguments, that remains to be answered is whether the corporate-political nexus has established its complete hegemony over the media reproduction of culture and whether the battle in the cultural field is over. On this point I would argue that notwithstanding all efforts of the power to establish its monopoly over media the alternative and critical voices are active fighting for its rightful, democratic place in the social media and this goes defying the State’s efforts to establish a surveillance regime backed with its colossal coercive power. One can look at how the popular cultural forms find expression and representation and how the different folk cultural forms and alternative art forms struggle for a space in the ambit of popular media. We must also take note of the fact that the mass media, specifically digitally supported social media platforms, are making pathways for such a democratic, counter-hegemonic upsurge through dialogical and dialectical negotiations with the mediated forms and striving to produce some authentic, aesthetic and counter-hegemonic discourses, often defying the hanging (or actual) threat of an authoritarian purge.

Notes

  1. The details of the concept of culture industry could be found in the chapter “Culture Industry: Enlightenment as Mass Deception” in the book Dialectic of Enlightenment (1944), where Theodor Adorno argues that culture industry in modern capitalist society, which constitute films, television, radio, magazines etc., produces culture as commodities for mass consumption and work for creating a homogeneous culture and ideological integration of the masses into the political order.
  2. Hyperreality, in postmodern condition, is an inability of consciousness to distinguish reality from a simulation of reality, especially in technologically advanced postmodern societies. Hyperreality is seen as a condition in which what is real and what is fiction are seamlessly blended together so that there is no clear distinction between where one ends and the other begins (Baudrillard 1988).
  3. Jurgen Habermas in the first volume of the book Theory of Communicative Action (1984) argues that the modern capitalist order has replaced the democratic public sphere with an order of distorted communication, which makes free speech, public debates and development of critical consciousness difficult; the task before the intelligentsia therefore is to fight for the creation of an “ideal speech community”.

References

  1. Baudrillard, Jean. 1988. ‘Simulacra and Simulations.’ In Mark Poster (ed.) Jean Baudrillard Selected Writings. Stanford, California: Stanford University Press: 166-184.
  2. Habermas, Jurgen. 1984 [1981]. The Theory of Communicative Action. Vol. I: Reason and the Rationalization of Society. T. McCarthy (trans.). Boston: Beacon.
  3. Horkheimer, Max and Theodor Adorno. 2002 [1944]. Dialectic of Enlightenment. Stanford, California: Stanford University Press.

Prof. Sanjay K. Roy

Browse

Search Results

Now showing 1 - 10 of 15
  • Thumbnail Image
    ItemOpen Access
    Digital Technology in Education: An Assessment
    (University of North Bengal, 2022-03) Kalet, Surendra; Pujari, Saswat Chandra
    Technology has positively changed the educational system in which we live. Digitalisation has enhanced the educational process, making it even more charming. Today, technology plays a crucial part in education. Traditional procedures have been supplanted by new modes of teaching and learning in education. Digital technology can assist students in gaining massive amounts of information, providing them with the ability to be self-directed and access to educational assets. But the positive effects that go along with the negative ones should not be overlooked. This paper discusses how diverse methods of teaching and learning could be suitable for students with the usage of digital technology; the importance of technology in the educational sector; and how the use of technology could open up new opportunities and bring challenges in the field of education.
  • Thumbnail Image
    ItemOpen Access
    Body Image and Presentation of Self among the Women University Students in Sikkim
    (University of North Bengal, 2022-03) Rai, Sunaina
    The spread modern technology and global flow of ideas and practices expedited by globalization, transnational capitalism and social media platforms have generated new discourses on human body. Under the spell of new body discourses modern men and women look for new identities and new ways of presentation of self in their everyday life. This paper reflects on how the university going women students of Sikkim perceive and negotiate with diverse body images in their everyday life. The first section of paper identifies the agents that influence construction of ideas on body and beauty. It also attempts to trace how far the socio-economic background of the students determines their perceptions of body and beauty. The second section attempts to unravel the various determining factors relating to the body discourse. It also traces the revolutionized social and cultural construction of body discourse based on the lived experiences and close observations within the family. The final section of this paper situates the empirical findings in the light of theoretical arguments and present the body discourse from a sociological standpoint.
  • Thumbnail Image
    ItemOpen Access
    Vendors’ Right to Market Space
    (University of North Bengal, 2022-03) Subba, Manita
    Vendors in Lall Market, Gangtok, come from different socioeconomic backgrounds and places, from different parts of India and Nepal. A large section of them constitutes the urban poor who make a living by doing petty trade while being a part of the urban informal economy. They have found vending as a way of earning their livelihood for themselves and their family. The right to livelihood is guaranteed as a Fundamental Right in the Indian Constitution; Article 21 guarantees the Right to Life and Personal Liberty. For the vendors, however, earning livelihood requires space from where they vend their goods, which is a contested space in the market place and hard to secure. The one who owns it and operates on it has to navigate their way through various social and administrative control and in that effort, the political participation of vendors plays a very important part in holding on to the place in the market. The paper aims to highlight the impact of the political participation of vendors in manoeuvring their way into the market space in availing the limited assets available.
  • Thumbnail Image
    ItemOpen Access
    Changing Birth Practices and Rituals among the Bengali Women in Siliguri
    (University of North Bengal, 2022-03) Sharma, Rukmani
    In this paper, I have attempted to make sense of the social ways in which Bengali women find themselves when they go through birth giving. Based on ethnographic study of Bengali women in Siliguri city, this work aims to understand the dynamics of cultural change and continuity vis-à-vis the practice of birth rituals in contemporary times. It examines the ways in which birth practices provide both the context and the medium for the social formation of gender, caste and community relations. The fieldwork insights demonstrate the decaying significance of traditional birth rituals and builds on women’s narratives about the birth as a social event in their personal and family lives. The work draws upon the conceptual and theoretical insights from the sociological literature on child birth and social and cultural experiences, social classification, identity and socialization.
  • Thumbnail Image
    ItemOpen Access
    Everyday Life of the Working Mothers during Covid-19 Pandemic
    (University of North Bengal, 2022-03) Bhutia, Winkeyla
    Following the Covid-19 pandemic and the subsequent lock downs leading to the closure of schools and other forms of institutional support, the workload of the working mothers has been amplified owing to the persistence of traditional gender roles and with the blurring of the private-public sphere division. This has been reflected more in the life of the women in the teaching profession who had to realign themselves to learn new technologies to facilitate remote teaching and learning while simultaneously doing childcare and other domestic chores. The present paper is based on a study of the women teachers in Sikkim and their life during the Covid-19 lockdown. The participants in the study were identified through the snowball sampling. The qualitative data has been collected through in-depth interviews with 16 mothers engaged in the teaching profession in Sikkim.
  • Thumbnail Image
    ItemOpen Access
    Construction and Negotiation of Identities among the Tibetan Refugees in India
    (University of North Bengal, 2022-03) Bhutia, Sonam Choden
    Tibetans fled Tibet after the Chinese occupation of the country in the year 1959. Tibetans have been living in exile for more than six decades and a large number of Tibetans have been born in host country India. Refugee hood of the Tibetans in India is a complex issue. Nonetheless, Tibetans born in India, are allowed to seek citizenship as per the enactment of the Indian Citizenship Act (Amendment) of 1986, which allows for acquiring of Indian citizenship by anyone born in India between January 26, 1950, and July 1, 1987. This has made a large section of the second and third generation Tibetans eligible for Indian citizenship. The young Tibetans are showing great interest in taking up Indian citizenship for many practical reasons; they want to have a secure livelihood and social existence and get rid of the confusions and dilemma among them over their sense of belongingness. No group of people can live with confusions about their identity or belongingness. This paper, therefore, has made an attempt to understand the Tibetans’ sense of belongingness by recording their personal narratives of their experiences in their everyday life. The paper locates the Tibetans living in India in terms of construction and negotiation of their identity vis-àvis Indian citizens in their everyday life.
  • Thumbnail Image
    ItemOpen Access
    Children and their Rights: Reflections on the Everyday Life of the Children in the Char Areas of Assam
    (University of North Bengal, 2022-03) Borah, Anindita
    This paper is an ethnographic account of children’s experiences in char areas of Assam from a sociological lens with special reference to child rights. From the 1970s onwards, social scientists have begun to consider children as social actors, as opposed to the idea of children as ‘incompetent and dependent beings’. It is argued that it is not always enough to make legal policies to solve children’s problems or see children’s well-being from an adult’s perspective, without considering them as their own agents. Children are now deemed as active members of society and they have the same rights as that of an adult to make their own understanding of the world. It is through the narrative of five children, selected from the char area, that I have analyzed various dimensions of their everyday life. The primary objective of this study has been to understand the everyday life of children in Bhomoraguri chapori from children’s perspective. Besides, this paper also explores various issues and challenges associated with the violation of child rights in the chapori.
  • Thumbnail Image
    ItemOpen Access
    The Everyday Life of the Hijras in Kolkata
    (University of North Bengal, 2022-03) Bhattacharya, Anwesha
    The hijras in India have always experienced liminal visibility in the mainstream society. The annulment of the penal code-377 is a recent progress made in empowering the hijras by the Supreme Court of India but much more needs to be accomplished. The hijras as a community have their identities rooted in Indian culture and tradition. These imbrication of the contours of definitions of identities creates liminal representation of many segments of the sexual minority and this amplifies in case of the hijras. The partial representation of hijras is specific to space and illustrates a close connection between space and gender performativity. The hijras demonstrate different versions of their sexuality depending on the place and context in which they are enacting. The reflections of a hijra’s lived experiences embark on the liminal representation and closeted performances showing the partial treatment of hijras in society. This paper focuses on how the under-representation of the hijras creates regular coercions and oppressive treatment of them both in public and private spaces. The hijra community has its own normative structure and it is embedded within the connotations of sexuality and gender. Therefore, the rights of the hijras are not safeguarded by the Constitution of India. Due to their ambiguous (conventional conception) sexuality the hijras are secluded from the mainstream society and receive skewed treatment and acknowledgement from the legal structure of India. The paper tries to draw a linkage between transsexuality, and liminal visibility and closeted performativity of hijras in Kolkata. The presence of inadequate laws accompanied with an absence of collective acceptance towards the ambiguity perceived as being embodied in the body of a hijra in Kolkata is the core theme of this paper.
  • Thumbnail Image
    ItemOpen Access
    Self-formation and Life of the Daughters in Marwari Community in Siliguri
    (University of North Bengal, 2022-03) Karmakar, Priyanka
    The preference for sons over daughters, which is a part of Pan-Indian culture, is more pronounced in some regions and among some communities; the Marwaris of Siliguri, is one such community. The Marwaris, who have migrated to Siliguri from Rajasthan, over the years, are a burgeoning business community in Siliguri, which is a flourishing business hub. The present paper, which is a part of my research in Siliguri, gives an ethnographic account of the Marwari community’s gender perception, especially son preference which they consider “natural” and acceptable because of the various socio-cultural and economic advantages associated with having a son. Such preferential treatment often results into the practice of daughter aversion and discrimination. The paper further demonstrates how the practice of son preference affects the self-formation of Marwari daughters who are made to grow up in an overpowering patriarchal culture and inculcate the values that help perpetuate gender discrimination.
  • Thumbnail Image
    ItemOpen Access
    Empathy: A Rule of Social Relations
    (University of North Bengal, 2022-03) Roy, Sinjini
    In the social science circle, it is widely claimed that modernity and the liberal ideology have brought a high degree of individualism, social differentiation, fragmentation and atomization in societies across the globe. The neo-liberal social order makes life highly competitive and insecure and creates new social hierarchies while promoting fetishized consumption, a false sense of consumption-based happiness while adding wind to the process of atomization. The inevitable casualty of this is the erosion of the collective social spirit based on fellow-feeling and attrition of compassion or empathy for the fellow members. Jean- Jacques Rousseau, Claude Levi-Strauss and many other social scientists have lamented this turn of events and given a call for rediscovering “pity” or “empathy” in social life and social management. Many social scientists are now echoing this need of the hour while drawing support for their discourses from the Buddhist philosophy and streams of modern Western philosophy. Broadly, the discussions on empathy or compassion as a social rule encompasses the question of morality and humanism in social praxis. This paper is an attempt to understand how empathy is conceived by some philosophers and social scientists and how it works in different shades in the life of the modern middleclass people in the urban Indian context.